7 Best Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Dupes

A concealer that is called shape tape must do wonders. And it does!

Since its launch, it has revolutionized the concept of a concealer in the beauty industry. The rave, my friends, is real. It has been one of the most popular and sought after concealers in the history of beauty.

Tarte is not a cheap brand, it has its scary price tags. Most people are not willing to pay such an amount for a concealer for valid reasons. People run out of concealers frequently and repurchasing such a high end concealer is not always realistic.

If you have been looking for Shape Tape concealer dupes, look no further. But as usual we will look at the Tarte concealer first!

Original Product: Tarte Shape Tape Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 35
  • Texture: Thick, Creamy
  • Benefits: Minimizes Creasing; Long-Lasting

This really is a concealer that puts other concealers to shame. No kidding.

Shape Tape is a full coverage concealer that does not look cakey at all. Unless you powder it too much, it sets beautifully and gives you a seamless look.

The formula is thick, yet creamy enough to work. With this, you can hide your dark circles, and your whole dating history. Trust me, I talk from experience!

If you still are not convinced, wait till you hear this- it truly minimizes creasing. On me it hardly ever creases and I have some very deep lines under my eyes. And that also suggests that it hardly budges throughout the day.

For me, it is a reliable concealer. The shade range is good and the undertones are quite forgiving. If I can use one concealer for life, this will be it.

But I only wish that one bottle lasted forever cause, repurchasing it is expensive. This reminds me, I was supposed to tell you about the dupes! Let us start!

7 Best Shape Tape Concealer Dupes

01. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Multi-Use Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 18
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Benefits: Radiant Finish; Buildable

Before Tarte Shape Tape, we had this, and this was it.

For starter, this creamy concealer does a good job at hiding your dark circles. It has a buildable formula that gives you full coverage like Shape Tape concealer.

You will notice that the finish is more radiant than Tarte. I think that is good for people who want a radiant under eye.

The texture is quite nice too. I will say this though, I do not enjoy the puff applicator. It just messes with the texture a bit. I feel that I would like the formula more if it had a different applicator, such as a wand.
The price is good though, so judge for yourself!

02. Maybelline New York Facestudio Master Conceal Makeup

Coverage: Full
Shade Range: 5
Texture: Creamy
Benefits: Hides Imperfections; Seamless Finish

Do I need to point out that the shade range is utterly disgraceful?

There is no excuse for that, really. But it is undeniable that the formula is quite similar to Shape Tape concealer. It is luxuriously creamy, and has a flexible consistency. This allows it to provide full coverage with a seamless finish!

With this, you can effortlessly hide your under eye dark circles. Although the shade range is small, the undertones pull a little warm and yellow. That ensures that the darkness is concealed without any ashy-ness. But of course, it is limited to a certain number of complexions.

So if you can find your shade, grab one, it is cheap!

03. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Full Wear Waterproof Matte Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 25
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Benefits: Water-Proof; Long-Wearing

If you need a close alternative to Shape Tape concealer, this will surely catch your attention.

This concealer shares a lot of similarities with the cult favorite Shape Tape. Coverage? The same, full! Texture? Creamy and buildable! Shade range? Almost close enough- 25!

You can apply this with ease and have a lot more working time with it than Shape Tape. This also has a matte finish, and looks great under your eyes and on your skin in general. A great benefit that it offers is that it is water-proof!

Of course, it is just as long-wearing. You can replace Tarte with this if you want, because it is definitely much kinder to your wallet!

04. COLOURPOP No Filter Matte Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 30
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Benefits: Blurring; Crease-Proof

A great contender, no doubt in that!

It challenges the Tarte concealer in every way, it mimics its move like a mirror almost! Firstly, great shade range, lovely undertones. That is one big chapter covered, job well done, Colourpop!

The texture is creamy and gives a full coverage, matte finish. It is similar to Shape Tape concealer, but not as drying. But the most important features are yet to be revealed!

This concealer blurs your imperfections as good as Tarte. It flawlessly covers up your blemishes and dark circles. Tarte is popular for tackling the creases and this concealer can also do that! It has a crease-proof formula that allows it to perform just as well as Tarte.

I absolutely enjoy this concealer, and its price is sort of low for the quality you receive!

05. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Dark Circle Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 4
  • Texture: Thick & Creamy
  • Benefits: Corrects & Conceals

I was mad at the shade range too, but then I sort of researched it.

As a concealer, yes, the shade range is unacceptable. But if we think of it as more of a color corrector, it somehow works.

Tarte is known for concealing the under eyes flawlessly. You can do that with this too. Because of its undertones, it helps cancel out the darkness. It will not brighten your under eyes like Tarte Shape Tape concealer, but it will hide those circles alright.

You will notice that the consistency is thick, creamy, and applies nicely with a dome shaped tapered brush. If you want, you can add a few dots of a brightening concealer to the get the full Shape Tape effect!

With more shades at this pricing, this concealer could hold some serious potential.

06. bareMinerals Barepro 16-Hour Full Coverage Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 15
  • Texture: Creamy (Stick)
  • Benefits: Water-Proof; Crease-Proof

A stick concealer that has an okay shade range, with nice undertones.

But that is not all that defines it. This concealer has the best of both worlds! Similar to Shape Tape, it has a crease-proof formula that keeps your under eyes looking flawless. On top of that, it is water-proof. So go swimming or cry your heart out- do whatever you want wearing this!

It will give you a nice, full coverage result that will last for hours. If you do not realize it already, this concealer can perform hard. For sure, try it and you will know.

Love the price, it is fair and affordable. It is all things good!

07. Dose of Colors Meet Your Hue Concealer

  • Coverage: Full
  • Shade Range: 30
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Benefits: Long-Lasting; Hydrating

This has got to be my favorite concealer. I love this more than Tarte!

It is slightly cheaper than Shape Tape concealer, which is not the only reason I am including this. This truly matches and performs just as well as Shape Tape, if not better.

Its creamy consistency makes it easy to blend it, and the result is a flawless full coverage finish. This will last all day long, and fight creasing throughout the day. Compared to Tarte, it is much more hydrating and does not feel drying at all.

The shade range is also quite well done- love the undertones. This really allows you to meet your hue, you know?

Overall, I love this! I have said this before but honestly, I would pick this over Tarte.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1# Will Tarte Shape Tape Concealer be Worth it?

Ans: I mean, sure! There is absolutely no reason that you will not like it. It lasts well, does not crease, and stays put. You will absolutely enjoy each penny spent on it.

But, it is sort of drying. So if that is something you cannot work with, then this is not for you!

Q2# Why is Tarte Shape Tape so Popular?

Ans: For many reasons! Firstly, Tarte’s quality is full-proof. This is a reliable formula that has your back. It handles the job of concealing under eyes flawlessly, and is multi-tasking too!

Having so many benefits all together, it has made its place and has earned its popularity!

Q3# Should I use Tarte Shape Tape Before or After Foundation?

Ans: This depends entirely upon you! Whatever looks and feels good to you, should do. For highlighting purposes, I suggest you use it after your foundation. But for concealing, either way works!

I personally use foundation first to assess how much more extra coverage I need, That helps me use the

right amount of concealer!

Q4# What is the Difference Between Shape Tape & Creaseless Concealer?

Ans: The main difference is in the formula! It is true that texture-wise both are nice and creamy. But the Creaseless Concealer is formulated to be more moisturizing.

Compared to that, Shape Tape is more matte and sort of drying.


The Tarte concealer rules the game, yes, but the completion is fierce.

The 7 best Shape Tape concealer dupes I suggested only attests to that! Each has at least a couple of similar features to Tarte. But I will let you be the judge of it!

Leave a Comment