7 Best Marc Jacobs Highliner Dupes

If eyes are truly the windows to our souls, then a good eyeliner is a must-have!

Marc Jacobs Highliner is highly acclaimed for its quality. However, not everyone has the wad of cash necessary to buy this product.

But don’t worry. I got you covered. I’ve rounded up the 7 best Marc Jacobs Highliner dupes that’ll make your makeup dreams come true.

Original Product: Marc Jacobs Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner Pencil

  • Eyeliner Type: Crayon/Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 26
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Smudge-free; Skin-friendly ingredients

This crayon eyeliner is perfect for people who don’t like the pointy edges of standard pencil eyeliners.

The creamy and malleable gel formula glides smoothly onto your lash line without pulling or tugging. And it lasts up to 12 hours without any smudging thanks to its waterproof formula.

The eyeliner also contains skin-friendly ingredients. More specifically, vitamin E and rosehip seed oil soothe and protect the delicate skin around the eyes.

It also has a built-in sharpener at the bottom.

Not to mention, there are 36 richly pigmented shades to choose from with original shimmer and high-impact matte finishes. Both the shimmer and matte versions have an impressive formula, color-payoffs, and wear-time.
Marc Jacobs Highliner is an amazing product, but it’s quite the splurge. However, there’s no need to shell out cash on it if you know about its 7 best dupes.

7 Best Marc Jacobs Highliner Dupes

1. L’Oréal Paris Infallible Eye Silkissime Eyeliner

  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 4
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Budge-proof

You can never go wrong with L’Oréal’s products.

This pencil eyeliner has a silky and smooth consistency, allowing for it to glide on like a dream. The formula is highly pigmented, so the color-payoff is visible even from the slightest touch of the pencil.

Once it sets, it literally won’t move – no matter how humid or rainy it is. Seriously though, it’s budge-proof for at least 16 hours.

You can sharpen it with L’Oréal Paris Dual Sharpener.

This one is definitely a steal so get and get it ASAP!


  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 18
  • Benefits: Waterproof

Watched a Netflix tearjerker movie? Well, don’t worry because this pencil eyeliner is waterproof.

You can use this to create a dramatic winged cat-eye or just a simple jet-black line. No matter what kind of look you create, you won’t have to worry about any annoying transfer spots. Plus, this baby will stay put without smearing or budging.

You can use a NYX sharpener or any other small-holed eyeliner sharpener to sharpen this one.

If you want high-performance eyeliner at a low price, this should be your go-to! It’s one of the best alternatives to Marc Jacobs Highliner.

3. Maybelline New York Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner

  • Eyeliner Type: Potted eyeliner
  • Shades: 10
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Smudge-proof

Potted eyeliners don’t always have the best reputation, but this one is quite the catch.

This gel eyeliner comes in a small transparent matte pot, and it comes with an applicator brush.

You just need a dip of the ink for the oil-free formula to glide on easily and precisely. The brush has a very thin edge that’ll allow you to effortlessly create the look you want.

It offers intense color for up to 24 hours. Trust me when I say that this won’t smudge, budge, or fade even after a long workday.

This eyeliner comes in 10 colorful hues. If you’re feeling fancy, I highly recommend the universally flattering shade of Eggplant purple.

This one is super gentle, so it’s especially suited for contact lens wearers and sensitive eyes.

4. COVERGIRL Ink It! By Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner

  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 6
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Crease-resistant

This dupe is impressive when it comes to ease of application and staying power.

Similar to Marc Jacobs Highliner, this gel-based eyeliner glides on smoothly without skipping, dragging, or pulling. Application is a breeze with this one. Plus, it’s a self-sharping pencil so it’s convenient to carry around.

It lasts up to 12 hours since it’s waterproof and crease-resistant.

And it’s cruelty-free!

Despite being one of the most affordable eyeliners out there, this one is completely mess-free and easy.

5. Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil

  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 4
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Transfer-resistant; Long-lasting

Say hello to your new holy grail!

This one does exactly what its name suggests. It stays put no matter what you do. Swim, shower, sweat, or sobs won’t stop this eyeliner from looking flattering on you.

The gel formula has super-saturated pigments, allowing your eyes to look defined. It’s also transfer-resistant and lasts up to 16 hours.

Like Marc Jacobs Highliner, this one is a creamy crayon-like eyeliner. If using a super fine-tipped pencil eyeliner is too difficult for you, then you should opt for this eyeliner.

6. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 8
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Long-lasting

Enliven and accentuate your eyes with this gem!

It has an ultra-silky formula that makes it easy to glide on accurately. It applies without dragging or pulling and leaves a pigmented color behind.

This Eyeliner stays put for up to 16 hours. And this one is a retractable eyeliner, meaning it doesn’t need to be sharpened. So, if don’t want to carry around a sharpener, this eyeliner is for you!

It’s ophthalmologist-tested and free from harsh ingredients like sulfates, parabens, and phthalates. It’s gentle on the eyes, making it a perfect fit for people with sensitive eyes.

This eyeliner will give you the definition you’ve been seeking!

Note: Be careful with the amount of pressure you use to apply this eyeliner. The tip can break pretty easily if too much pressure is applied.

7. IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Gel Eyeliner

  • Eyeliner Type: Pencil eyeliner
  • Shades: 8
  • Benefits: Waterproof; Long-lasting

This gel eyeliner has been developed with dermatologists’ expertise and plastic surgeons’ insights. That means that the ingredients and formula are good for the skin.

This eyeliner has a soft and silky feel, allowing it to glide on easily. The formula is super blendable so you can create any look you want. It’s also waterproof and promises to hold tight for all-day wear.

The 8 shades that it offers are rich and saturated. These shades have intense color-payoffs so they will enhance the appearance and colors of your eyes.

Note: It doesn’t come with a sharpener. You will have to either buy one separately or use a pencil sharpener.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1# How do I sharpen an eyeliner pencil?

Ans: Fortunately, most brands will have a sharpener designed specifically for use with their eyeliners. So, you should sharpen the eyeliner pencil with that special sharpener the same way you’d sharpen a pencil.

But if you never get a sharpener that comes with the eyeliner, then you can use a regular pencil sharpener. However, this might be a bit difficult since the eyeliner pencil might not fit into a regular pencil sharpener. Let’s hope practice makes perfect!

Oh, and keep in mind that some eyeliner pencils are retractable, meaning they don’t require sharpening.

Q2# How do I use Marc Jacobs Highliner?

Ans: You can use it however you want to create any kind of look you want! But the brand states that it can be used in four techniques to create different looks: line, smudge, layer, and design.

Marc Jacobs Highliner is easy to maneuver. Make sure to prep your eyes with an eyeshadow primer first.

Then, press the tip of the crayon eyeliner into the roots of your lashes. Glide it along the lash line from the inner corner out to the end. And make sure to wait at least 15 seconds for it to set!

Q3# Does Marc Jacobs Highliner last the whole day?

Ans: As I mentioned before, it lasts up to 12 hours! I’d say that’s pretty long. And since it’s water-resistant, you won’t have to worry even when you’re sweating or swimming.

Q4# Is Marc Jacobs Highliner worth it?

Ans: Considering wear-time, finish, and the way it wears on the skin, Marc Jacobs Highliner is an excellent value. The accolades it gets are not undeserved since it’s an amazing value for what it offers.

However, for people who are not willing to spend that much on eyeliner, I recommend the dupes mentioned here.


There you go! These were some of the best Marc Jacobs Highliner dupes.

You don’t have to spend a ton to get an incredible eyeliner that you’ll obsess over. There are so many affordable options available in the market! I hope you find a dupe that meets your budget and performs magically!

Leave a Comment