7 Best Benefit Erase Paste Dupes

Concealers work like magic. Apply a small amount to your problem areas and it’ll make you forget that your imperfections even exist.

There has been a large cloud of hype encircling over Benefit Erase Paste for some time. However, there are dupes with lower price points that perform just as well.

I’ve rounded up the absolute best dupes for you to check out. So keep reading to find out about the 7 best Benefit Erase Paste dupes.

Original Product: Benefit Erase Paste


  • Shade Range: 3
  • Coverage: Full
  • Benefits: Brighten complexion

This thick and creamy concealer has a peachy tint and is formulated with melon undertones. It does a fine job at concealing dark circles, discoloration, and imperfections. It also reduces signs of stress and fatigue.

A little goes a long way with this one. Try to avoid using too much because it can lead to a tacky and cakey finish. If you do it right, it will blend smoothly and leave you with a slightly dewy finish.

Plus, the packaging is super cute and perfect for travel!

Although Benefit Erase Paste has achieved an impressive fan following, bougie doesn’t always mean better. There are so many fabulous dupes out there! So continue reading to learn about them!

7 Best Benefit Erase Paste Dupes

1. Pixi Correction Concentrate Concealer

  • Shade Range: 2
  • Coverage: Medium to Full
  • Benefits: Skin-loving ingredients; Brightens complexion

The makers weren’t exaggerating when they called this concealer a “good night’s sleep in a jar.”

Pixi Correction Concentrate Concealer is full of skin-loving ingredients like vitamins A and C. It also contains rosehip extract which is known to improve skin elasticity.

This is a highly pigmented concealer with a peach nude tone that counteracts darkness and discoloration. It also does a pretty good job of brightening the under-eye area. In addition, it has an incredible staying power.

However, keep in mind that this product is pretty dry so proper moisturizing and priming beforehand is essential.

So what are you waiting for? Banish your dark circles with this fantastic concealer!

2. NYX Professional Makeup Dark Circle Concealer

  • Shade Range: 4
  • Coverage: Medium to Full
  • Benefits: Long-lasting

Did an all-nighter to meet a tight deadline? Or stayed up late partying? Either way, you won’t need to worry about looking tired and fatigued if you have this product!

This color-correcting concealer has a subtle hint of orange that will reduce the appearance of dark circles. Similar to Benefit Erase Paste, it will instantly make you look refreshed and bright-eyed.

Coconut oil is a key ingredient in this concealer that moisturizes the skin and ensures no caking. The coconut oil also allows for this creamy concealer to glide on easily. You won’t have to worry about it creasing or settling on your fine lines.

It lasts for a pretty long time so reapplication isn’t necessary.

Shoot, at this point I can probably write an entire essay about how stellar this product is!

3. IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Under Eye Concealer

  • Shade Range: 48
  • Coverage: Full
  • Benefits: Anti-aging ingredients; Waterproof

Look and feel younger with this miracle-worker! This concealer has been developed with the help of plastic surgeons.

This concealer is especially recommended for mature skin that’s dry around the eyes. This is because the concealer is infused with amazing anti-aging and moisturizing ingredients. It contains anti-aging peptides, hyaluronic acid, antioxidants, and vitamins A, C, and E.

Additionally, this is a multitasking concealer. It reduces the appearance of dark circles, redness, discoloration, hyperpigmentation, age spots, and any other skin issues.

Oh, and did I mention that it’s available in 48 inclusive shades? Plus, it’s waterproof!

I hope you realized by now that this product has the potential to become your new holy grail. It’s the perfect alternative to Benefit Erase Paste.

4. Revlon PhotoReady Candid Concealer

  • Shade Range: 18
  • Coverage: Sheer to Medium
  • Benefits: Long-lasting; Natural-looking finish

Hooray for this budget-friendly option!

It contains anti-pollution, antioxidant, and anti-blue light ingredients. And it’s suitable for sensitive skin since it’s fragrance-free, paraben-free, and oil-free.

Since this concealer comes with a doe-foot applicator, it’s easy to apply on the delicate eye area. You just need to dot, dot, dot, and then blend carefully with a damp sponge.

Like Benefit Erase Paste, this concealer beautifully camouflages under-eye puffiness and dark circles while keeping cakiness at bay. It’s also blendable, buildable, and long-lasting. And most importantly, it delivers a moisturizing coverage and a natural-looking finish.

5. Wet n Wild Photo Focus Concealer

  • Shade Range: 6
  • Coverage: Full
  • Benefits: Lightweight; Brightens complexion

Say goodbye to dark circles with this product!

This easy-to-use lightweight concealer will instantly illuminate your under-eye area. You simply have to dot the doe-foot applicator under your eyes or any other problem areas. You can then blend it with your hand or with a sponge or brush.

This concealer will immediately brighten your complexion and make you look fresh. Your dark circles, blemishes, and other imperfections will magically disappear after applying this product.

You’ll be pleasantly surprised with just how good this concealer is.

6. Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Concealer Stick

  • Shade Range: 5
  • Coverage: Sheer to Medium
  • Benefits: Hydrating; Lit-from-within glow

If you have dry and thirsty skin, then give this concealer a try! I promise that you won’t be disappointed.

This concealer stick is creamy and hydrating. This is because it contains purified hyaluronic acid, a skin-plumping ingredient known for its hydrating and moisturizing properties.

This concealer is as light as a feather, gliding on smoothly and blending effortlessly. And the result? A minimized look of imperfections and a gorgeous lit-from-within glow.

And guess what? It’s oil-free, non-greasy, and non-comedogenic, making it a perfect choice for sensitive skin. Isn’t that just downright amazing?

7. Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser

  • Shade Range: 18
  • Coverage: Full
  • Benefits: Lightweight; Skin-friendly ingredients

You really can’t afford NOT to try this concealer!

This one is travel-friendly and super easy to use. The product is in a twist-up tube with a built-in cushy sponge applicator. After a few twists, the sponge will rise to the top.

You can press the sponge on your under-eye circles to get rid of the darkness. Since this is a multi-use product, you can also use it to cover any dark spots or blemishes.

This product is highly pigmented but has an extremely thin consistency. Since it’s lightweight and thin, it glides on like butter and blends easily. It also has a skin-friendly ingredient called goji berries which improves the look of fine lines.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1# How do I choose the right shade of concealer for my skin?

Ans: Finding the right shade can be tricky. But here are some general rules of thumb:

Choose a shade that’s no more than one or two shades lighter than your skin tone.

If you have a light to medium skin tone, try something with a peach undertone. If you have a darker skin tone, a concealer with an orange undertone is recommended.

Q2# Are Benefit Cosmetics’ concealers good?

Ans: Yes! Benefit Cosmetics constantly revamps its concealer line and continues to produce some really amazing products. In addition to Benefit Erase Paste, there are other magical concealers in the Benefit Boi-ing line.

Q3# How do I use Benefit Erase Paste?

Ans: Benefit Erase Paste actually comes with a step-by-step lesson sheet with tips and tricks. It also comes with a mini-spatula to make application easier.

Here’s the step-by-step lesson:

Use the mini-spatula to scoop the concealer out.

Apply it to the back of your hand and use your ring finger to gently blend it.

For your under-eye area, blend the concealer from the outer corner to the inner corner.

For your blemishes, draw an “X” over the problem area. Then, pat and blend.

Pretty simple right?

Q4# Should I buy Benefit Erase Paste?

Ans: If you have the money to splurge, then yes! You deserve to treat yourself with this miraculous concealer. Apart from the price tag, you won’t find anything to complain about when it comes to this product.

However, if you don’t want to splurge, try the dupes that I have mentioned in this article.


Concealer is a makeup essential since it’s the secret to looking like you had a restful night’s sleep. It brightens up the skin, corrects color, and blurs imperfections.

Don’t want to shell out your hard-earned money on high-end products like Benefit Erase Paste? Then do yourself and your bank account a favor by trying the 7 best Benefit Erase Paste dupes.

Related Article:

Leave a Comment